For college football fanatics ONLY

Author: rickro51 Page 14 of 31

An Epic Confrontation: Sparty versus UM

Next Saturday will mark the Odyssey’s return to Spartan Stadium after a 48-year hiatus!!  Never have the bitter instate rivals faced each other undefeated at this stage of a season.

Just how much has college football changed over the past 50 years? We offer the following anecdotal evidence from the Odyssey’s other visit to East Lansing for a UM-MSU game in 1971.  Michigan won a 24-13 slog in front of MSU’s largest home attendance ever to date, 80,000+.  Tom Slade, the UM starter, threw a total of 9 passes, completing 3 for a whopping 45 yards.  UM fans are ever grateful that another Tom, Brady, was too young to witness Bo Schembechler’s cave man approach to play calling.  He never would have ventured East from San Mateo.

In 1971, the Odyssey learned first-hand just how passionate Spartan fans are  when the Wolverines visited.  Schembechler, to his considerable regret, had learned that hard lesson 2 years earlier.  In the Ohioan’s first visit to East Lansing as UM’s head coach, the wily Duffy Daugherty, made one of the most brilliant maneuvers in this rivalry.  The previous week, MSU was embarrassed, 54-21, to an Ohio State team that had been considered one of the all-time best squads.  Daugherty unveiled a triple option offense that caught the Wolverines with their pants down.  MSU scored a 23-12 upset that would prove to be UM’s only 1969, Big Ten loss.  Post-game, Schembechler ruefully admitted that he did fully grasp how intense the rivalry was.  Bo learned his lesson exceptionally well.  He would finish with a 17-4 record against the Spartans and with one exception, in 1987, the crusty Schembechler would never lose again in East Lansing.

Michigan’s vaunted defense will be tested Saturday.  MSU again has very talented receivers, Jayden Reed and Jalen Nailor,  while Michigan still has  cornerbacks Gemon Green and Vincent Gray that were torched in MSU’s 27-24  upset win last year.  Mel Tucker has done an amazing job, using the transfer portal for both quality and quantity.  He plucked Kenneth Walker from Wake Forest and has been rewarded with Walker’s gaudy stats that have made him a Heisman contender. (The Odyssey wonders what Wake Forest’s prolific offense would be like if Walker had elected to stay in Winston Salem).

One big change in UM’s defensive philosophy in  2021 will impact this game.  In previous years, Don Brown, dubbed “Dr. Blitz”, would often leave his corners in man-to-man coverage.    This approach was often successful but its limitations were glaringly obvious in last year’s MSU game as well as the past two games against Ohio State’s other worldly receivers where the Buckeyes embarrassed the UM D to the tune of 118 points.  Jim Harbaugh parted ways with Brown and instituted a more conservative defensive approach.

The key to the game may well come down to how well an improved MSU offensive line can handle a very talented Wolverine defensive line, headed by legacy Aidan Hutchinson.  If MSU can hold the Blue’s D Line at bay, we believe the home crowd will go home happy.  Otherwise, …….

 

 

Aztec Frustration

Imagine yourself as a recruiter for truck drivers.  Given our acute supply-side issues to retailers, this is a very timely job, especially with the large reduction in the number of truckers in recent years.  You are not a sports fan and spy Brady Hoke.  Wouldn’t your first inclination be to offer him a signing bonus on the spot?  Because who looks more like a truck driver than Brady Hoke?

Hoke is the coach of an undefeated San Diego State team that heads to Air Force on Saturday.  As usual, the Aztecs possess a primitive defense that seriously restricts access to their end zone.  This calling card has been a constant over the past dozen years.  Combined with a running game that has featured Donnel Pumphrey, Rashaad Penny and, now, Greg Bell, the Aztecs have had considerable success. In SDSU’s last 9 games against their Big Brother, the Pac-12, the Aztecs sport a gaudy 7-2 mark.

Now comes the “but”!  Last Friday’s game was a 6-6 slog at the end of regulation against San Jose State.  Lucas Johnson came off the bench to throw his only two completions of the game, both TDs, in SDSU’s 19-13 double OT triumph.

California breeds quarterbacks in the same way Spring features flowers.  Why cannot San Diego State get one?  To characterize Aztec QBs over the past decade as “game managers” might be an insult to game managers.  Off the top of my head, the last Aztec gunslinger who scared opponents was Ryan Lindley – more than a decade ago.

Thus, a memo to Coach Hoke:  Do not come off as a truck driver and hit the California roads hard in search of a QB with an arm.  As it is, the Aztecs’ formidable run defense takes on an Air Force rushing game which is numero uno in the country.  Expect another rock fight and hope that Coach Hoke develops a good gift of gab in the recruiting wars.  Because if SDSU gets a quality QB and retains the above attributes, the sky is the limit.

Doomed Doormats

One element that absolutely separates college ball from the NFL is the lack of parity in the college game.  Thus, there are many more blowouts but when David rises to smite Goliath, great theater results.  I root for the Davids of the world as they endure so much disappointment in their frequent roles as sacrificial lambs.

Saturday, hapless Vanderbilt was the beneficiary of 4 South Carolina turnovers and was nursing a 20-14 lead with just over a minute remaining.  The Gamecocks had exhausted their timeouts.  They promptly moved on a 75-yard drive to win the game, 21-20.  I was nauseous the entire drive.  Vanderbilt had varied its quarterback pressures during the game to reasonably good success.  On South Carolina’s game-winning drive, Vandy rushed only 3 on every play.  Backup QB, Zeb Noland,  had all day to throw.  If Vandy had 8 folks patrolling the passing lanes, no clear evidence existed as the Gamecocks effortlessly breezed down the field.

A sage once opined: “The prevent defense prevents you from winning.”  AMEN.  The defense called in the 6oth minute was so lame that we wonder if first-year coach Clark Lea will lose his team.

My anger turned into amazement Saturday evening by a stunning turnaround by another have not, Louisiana Monroe.  Being down 14-0 against a quality Liberty squad at halftime was no surprise since Liberty went off as a 32-point favorite.  What was shocking was that an often moribund offense exploded for 4 TD’s behind a backup QB.  At 28-28, after much thought, ULM elected to try a 53-yard field goal.  GOOD and the season’s biggest upset came to pass.  Regrettably, there were too few fans in attendance to have a proper field storming.  Oh, well, you can’t have everything.

Offenses Keep On Exploding

Several non-stop trends to note in the 21st century:

Global warming (sadly)

More strikeouts in baseball

Offenses besting defenses in college football.

The Red River Rivalry has been played  117 times (62-50-5 in favor of Texas).    Check out the dates of the 4 highest scoring games in the fabled Texas-Oklahoma series:

2021      OU 55, Texas 48

2020      OU 53, Texas 45

2018       Texas 48, OU 45   “Dicker the Kicker”

2016       OU  45, Texas 40

Notice a trend??

Another benchmark of defensive futility.  Check out some defensive stats of Arkansas State, a respected Sun Belt program that has spawned the Power 5 coaching careers of Gus Malzahn, Hugh Freeze and Bryan Harsin during the past decade.

VERSUS:

Memphis                                 680 yards of defense

Washington                            367 yards of passing defense to an anemic offense that                                                       scored a total of 17 points in its prior 2 games

Tulsa                                        663 yards of defense

Georgia State                          503 yards of rushing defense

Coastal Carolina                    683 yards of defense

Even Arkansas State’s new coach, Butch Jones, must be wordless at this point — no small feat since Jones is the master of meaningless platitudes.

Not convinced yet?  Then you probably did not watch Ole Miss’ 52-51 thriller over Arkansas which featured three TD’s in the last 82 seconds of the game.  In August, Alabama’s D was reputed to be one of its best in a decade.  What does offensively-challenged Texas A&M do with its backup QB against the Tide:  41 points!!  Have they cleared the fans off the field yet in College Station?

Probably just as well that Bo and Woody have passed on.  If they had not, they might have had coronaries  watching 21st-century defenses flail away.

 

 

Thank You, ESPN!

Last Saturday night was a programming first for ESPN.  A regular season game between two FCS schools, Eastern Washington and Montana, was broadcast on ESPN2 in prime time.  Likely this was a byproduct of a spectacular September for the Big Sky, where the conference could boast of 4 FBS scalps (ranked Washington, Arizona, UNLV and Tulsa).

Based on the thriller, ESPN should offer more FCS broadcasts.  Eastern Washington survived, 34-28, but only after a pass in the end zone was batted away on the game’s final play.

Vibrant would be a vast understatement for all aspects associated with one of the very best games of the year.  Eastern Washington’s red turf, dubbed the “Inferno”, does make one feel that they are at the Gates of Hell.  The nation got to see EWU’s stellar QB, Eric Barriere, who once again threw for over 400 yards.  The winner of this game would be in line to receive a top seed in the FCS playoffs.

Fortunately, ESPN+ does offer a lot of FCS telecasts.   There are excellent FCS tilts most weekends.  You could do lots worse than to watch North Dakota State vs Northern Iowa  and/or South Dakota State vs Southern Illinois.

Don’t feel that you are slumming by enjoying FCS football!  Stream away!!

 

The Misery Bowl

The media is so playoff-obsessed that many interesting stories are given short shrift.   Saturday, in Amherst, Massachusetts,  is going to provide both temporary relief and ample joy to one team.

UConn will make a quick 50-mile road trip to play UMass.  One team will emerge victorious.  Neither team has won a game since 2019!  Future prospects for both programs are beyond bleak.  Both teams are orphans, relegated to independent status.  Scheduling games becomes a nightmare once conference play around the country starts in earnest.

Arguably, UMass never should have ascended to FBS status.  UConn is in perhaps a more painful situation.  UMass is a “never was” in the highest tier of football.  When UConn left 1-AA football in 2000 and later landed in the Big East, not only were the Huskies in a strong conference, UConn experienced success.  As 2010 co-champs, the Huskies represented the Big East in the Fiesta Bowl.  Heady times.  Their coach, Randy Edsall, abruptly left for Maryland and the program careened downward.  The Big East imploded as a football conference but the Huskies found a landing spot in the American Athletic Conference.

The death knell for UConn fortunes came when their abysmal record and indifferent attendance led the American Athletic Conference to kick the Huskies to the curb.  In utter desperation, UConn rehired Randy Edsall, a move so disastrous that he “retired” after the 2nd game of 2021, a 38-28 clunker to FCS Holy Cross. Car buffs might label his 2nd tenure as a real Edsel.

Post-Edsel, UConn, unlike UMass, has come to life and stopped sputtering the past 2 Saturdays.  Last Saturday, UConn QB, Steven Krajewski, scored on a 17-yard scamper with 1:07 left to put UConn ahead of Vanderbilt, 28-27.  However, the D did not do their part and allowed Vandy to walk it off with a 31-yard field goal.  UConn’s performance in their previous game was stunning.  UConn scored a TD against unbeaten Wyoming with 4 seconds left to make the score 24-22 but could not convert the tying, 2-point conversion.

The Odyssey sees no viable path for either to continue at the FBS level in any meaningful fashion. If they persist in their FBS status,  we do suggest that the teams schedule each other 6 times a year.  Not only is the short travel ecologically attractive, winning does solve some problems.  Their mutual issues seem so massive the older elements of their fan bases might yearn for the long gone days of the Yankee Conference.

The experts in the desert have put the total points in the game at 55.  With these defenses?  Seems a touch low to the Odyssey.

What we do know is that the players on both squads have put in so much effort for so little reward.  We wish both teams could win on Saturday.  For the winners, there is a going to be a hell of a celebration come Saturday evening.  Well deserved!!

Way Too Entitled!

K’Vaughn Pope is an Ohio State linebacker — check that — WAS an Ohio State linebacker.  Disgruntled at being subbed out in last Saturday’s Akron, Pope stormed off the field, ripped off his uniform and later tweeted “F*ck Ohio State”  He has been dismissed from the team.

Others have dismissed themselves.  Utah embraced Charlie Brewer.  Brewer gave up on his chance to start games at Baylor for a 5th straight year.  Brewer expressed a desire to go to a winning program.    This felt like a slap in the face to a program that believed in Brewer.  Brewer, who prepped at Austin’s Lake Travis, always wanted to follow in the footsteps of numerous family members who had been Longhorn QB’s.  His dad, Robert, was the MVP of the 1982 Cotton Bowl.  Baylor offered Charlie.  The Longhorns did not.  Brewer was having a tough day against San Diego State and was benched in the third quarter.  Less than 48 hours after his benching, Brewer said goodbye to the Utes.  Possibly Brewer thought he was being loyal to the Utes — after all, he could have called for an uber to LAX at the end of the 3rd quarter of the San Diego State game.   Meanwhile, Baylor upset Iowa State last Saturday to start 2021 with a 4-0 bang.

Bailey Hockman was also benched two Saturdays ago during Middle Tennessee’s game at Texas San Antonio.  Less than 48 hours later, he announced his retirement from football for family reasons.  Was there a family emergency on the Sunday after his benching?  Perhaps nobody should be surprised that Hockman continued to be a rolling stone.  He had previously been at Florida State and North Carolina State.  Thankfully, for Middle Tennessee, the Blue Raiders finally found the right QB to lead their team, Chase Cunningham.  Cunningham has had his disappointments the previous 2 years but he stayed the course.  The Odyssey was in attendance last Friday night in Charlotte as Cunningham threw for 389 yards in an excellent effort for the Blue Raiders.

Like Cunningham, another QB showed that perseverance can pay off after being benched.  Jeff Sims had given way to Jordan Yates at the Georgia Tech QB.  Sims came off the bench and was stellar in the Yellow Jackets’ 45-22 upset of North Carolina last weekend.  We salute the perseverance of both Cunningham and Sims!

As for folks like Brewer, Pope and Hockman, the Odyssey says “good riddance.”  Even as crazy as the antics of Georgia Southern lineman Gavin Adcock were last Saturday (chugging beer on top of a moving bus in pre-game!!!), we know that we would even prefer the Gavin Adcocks of the world to ungrateful quitters if forced to choose.

Visiting Charlotte and the Hokies

Friday night, we were in Charlotte at one of the unique FBS stadiums.  The stadium capacity is the smallest in FBS (if you exclude that the Hawaii Rainbow Warriors are playing in temporary digs) at 15,314.  Building an on-campus stadium this small is either pessimistic or genius, depending on your perspective.  For most Group of 5 programs with larger capacities, empty seats tend to be plentiful.  For example, the Odyssey was appalled at the vast swaths of empty seats at the September 16, Thursday night game when Louisiana hosted Ohio, particularly when Louisiana is one of the most ballyhooed Group of 5 teams.  One further element  in the decision to have a smaller stadium: Charlotte is an NFL town.  Generally, this saps the energy and the fan base for the local college team.  That the Washington Huskies draw reasonably well in Seattle is a case of the exception proving the rule.

Even though the Middle Tennessee-Charlotte did not rate to be must-watch football, in addition to being saddled competition from local Friday night prep games, the atmosphere was of a well attended game despite attendance of 11,000.  Chalk up one vote for genius.  Further, the fans went home both entertained and happy as the 49ers held off Middle Tennessee, 42-39,  Both Chase Cunningham and Chris Reynolds passed for over 300 yards in a tilt with ample offensive fireworks to the tune of 1,059 yards.

The second unique aspect of Charlotte’s stadium is that its omnipresent bricks strongly suggest design and construction by a mason.  Even the Engineering Halls that overlook the North end zone conjure memories of the Commodores’ “Brick House”.

Saturday, we eagerly looked to “Enter Sandman” as Virginia Tech’s players enter Lane Stadium to perhaps college football’s most passionate welcome.  If only the Hokies were able to retain such passion for FCS foe, Richmond.  Virginia Tech’s opening TD drive was as easy as a knife through better.  Two series later, Justin Fuente stuck in his backup quarterback, Knox Kadum   What could go wrong in a game where the QB of an FCS team has already gone down?   Turns out, plenty!   A Richmond pick and a very short field resulted in a 7-7 score.

The Hokies slept walked through a 21-10 triumph over the Spiders.  The offense proved a massive disappointment, as one of their TDs was provided courtesy of a  60-yard punt return by Tayvion Robinson.  Braxton Burmeister throws a  ball as pretty as his hometown of La Jolla but we wonder if is capable of being the field general needed by Virginia Tech to win the ACC.

Richmond suffered some terrible luck on their first drive which seriously put into question any chance of an upset.  Their run-first QB, Joe “Macho Man” Mancuso, galloped wild for 29 yards on Richmond’s second play from scrimmage.  Dinged up on the hit, his initial carry  also proved to be his last carry.  At least he can brag to his grandkids that he averaged 29 yards a rush at Lane Stadium.

If the day provided any consolation to Virginia Tech, more proof was provided that Clemson is no longer a super team as they fell at NC State in double overtime.  With their key victory over North Carolina in hand, the Hokies have a lot to play for in coming ACC contests.

 

 

It was a real hAPPening!

Even if Appalachian State did not have a quality football program, driving to Boone, North Carolina would have easily been worthwhile for the picturesque scenery.  Breathtaking!  6 miles before you hit Boone you drive through one of the cutest and most aptly-named towns in the country: Blowing Rock.  Having previously visited North Carolina’s beaches, one develops a great appreciation for the state’s varied topography.

Marshall’s visit was a gift, producing a high-quality, evenly matched affair.  Marshall was one shoestring tackle away from having 2 kick return TDs in the first half!  The Odyssey was intensely interested in the play of both QBs, because both have had weird,  uneven careers.

For App QB, Chase Brice, Boone is his 3rd stop.  As a Clemson backup, his one blaze of Tiger QB glory was in a victorious 2018 relief stint in a nailbiting 27-23 comeback win over Syracuse after Clemson’s all-world QB, Trevor Lawrence, was hurt.  That Brice played in the game was a bit of a fluke since he was the 3rd string QB entering 2018.  However, Kelly Bryant abruptly left the team after he lost the starting gig to the freshman wunderkind.  In 2020, Brice started at Duke was an integral component of a turnover-filled horror fest.  Today, college football QBs move at the drop of a hat.  Would Brice rebound in the third chapter of his “See the Carolinas” tour?

Marshall QB, Grant Wells, has refreshingly stayed at one locale.  However, the last 3 games of 2020 morphed into his own personal horror show after Marshall’s scintillating 7-0 start to their 2020 campaign.  Marshall scored a total of 23 points in his last 3 starts which was a real shame as the defense played well enough in each of those losses.  His tailspin brought the Marshall offense to a screeching halt and certainly contributed to the end of Doc Holliday’s 11-year tenure as the coach of the Thundering Herd.  That Wells threw for 433 yards last Saturday against East Carolina last Saturday indicated that his 2020 meltdown was temporary.

Happy to say that both acquitted themselves well, or “wells” in the case of Marshall’s QB, particularly on longish throws. However, Wells does not play defense.  For the 2nd time in 5 days, the Marshall D collapsed in the 4th quarter, as the Herd could not hang on to a 2-possession lead.  App, down 30-21, pulled out a 31-30 nailbiter.  While the winning points were provided by the toe of a 45-yard field goal by Chandler Staton with 4:32 to go, we were very impressed by both the intellect and unselfishness of   Nate Noel .  With a minute to go,  Noel  broke away from the Herd and apparently was on his way to score a TD.  However, he halted progress at the Marshall 5-yard line and basically allowed himself to be tackled.  Marshall did not have enough timeouts left to keep the clock alive.  Ballgame.  If App had scored to make the score 38-30, Marshall would have had a minute for a last-gasp comeback.

The App crowd of 28,000 deserves many kudos.  The Odyssey has never heard a crowd of this size make so much noise.  The cacophony did not stop at game’s end as loud, post-game revelry continued for a good 15 minutes.  A proud night for a proud program!

With TV’s saturation programming, in-game attendance has been affected the past decade.  With this in mind, the Odyssey is saddened that Wake Forest and Virginia Tech do not schedule regular regional tilts with the Mountaineers.  Wake, with your flagging attendance, please do not be too proud!

For those who think that App State is a Johnny-Come-Lately program, you would be wrong.  Even prior to App’s earthshaking 2007 upset at The Big House, you can point back to games of 40+ years ago where App would come down the mountain and upset Wake.  In fact, Appalachian State and Marshall were Southern Conference rivals when both teams were FCS powers.

As for Marshall, you have to be one of the best 2-2 teams in college football.  Either finish better or come to a pre-game agreement with the opponents that you will only play 55 minutes.

Yet Another Odyssey Tripleheader

The Odyssey looks forward to the beauty of the Appalachian and the Blue Ridge mountains this weekend.

Thursday night, App State will host a Marshall team  smarting over an epic collapse.  For 11 quarters, the Thundering Herd had been riding roughshod over its outmatched opponents.  Holding a 38-21 lead at home early in the fourth quarter against East Carolina, Marshall was facing a 4th and 2 at the ECU 22.  The Herd passed up on a field goal attempt as a fade route failed to get a soul-crushing first down.  Marshall missed a 31 yard field goal attempt after ECU had scored to narrow the gap to 38-28.  ECU scored again on a trick play with 2:30 to go as QB Holton Ahlers caught a 27-yard TD pass from a wide receiver. ECU recovered an onside kick and scored the go-ahead touchdown with 55 seconds to go.  Undaunted, Marshall quickly marched down to the ECU 15 but JaQuan McMillian intercepted a Marshall pass at the goal line to mar a 433-yard passing day by Grant Wells.  Defense in the tilt was optional as 1,218 yards of offense attested.  Will Marshall still have a hangover with such a short turnaround? Stay tuned.

If East Carolina is a barometer, App State should have an edge as their defense was much more able to keep the dangerous Holton Ahlers at bay in their opener against the Pirates.

Charlotte will be hosting Middle Tennessee on Friday night.  We expect the 49ers to fare well against a Middle team that is, charitably,  middling.  Charlotte opened with a thrilling last-minute victory over Duke.  While experts thought the 2021 Dukies would be underwhelming, Duke has a potent offense and has followed up with 2 impressive victories.  Last Saturday, the unpredictability of college football again was on demonstration.  A Georgia State defense that had been thrashed in its first two games, allowing 109 points, finally showed up.  In addition, Georgia State made a needed QB change.  The rejuvenated Panthers shockingly limited Charlotte to 9 points in a 20-9 triumph.  We thought fourth-year starting QB, Chris Reynolds, and the rest of the 49er offense would fare much better.  We expect a close game where the home field may prove the difference.

On Saturday, we will return to the mountains and will eagerly listen as “Enter Sandman” again electrifies the Blue Ridge.  Virginia Tech entertains FCS Richmond at noon.  The Hokies almost pulled off a memorable comeback at West Virginia and will want to rinse away the taste of their frustrating 27-21 defeat.  Virginia Tech’s downfall was caused by total failures after three different occasions of first and goal to go:  Result; zero points!  Toss in yet another failure for Hokies when they did not convert a 4th and 1 from the West Virginia 25 and you have the recipe for defeat in front of the passionate Mountaineer fans.

Strangely, Richmond’s season closely parallels that of Marshall.  The Spiders opened with 2 impressive victories and then let a double-digit lead in the fourth quarter slip away against Villanova.  Villanova scored 3 TDs in the final five minutes (!!) to pull a 34-27 rabbit out of the hat.  We do not expect a Virginia Tech letdown.  The Hokie coaching staff will no doubt be reminding their team of their 2010 loss to FCS’s James Madison in the aftermath of their ballyhooed, heartbreaking opening loss to Boise that the Odyssey attended in Landover. One other reason that the “boys from VPI” will not overlook Richmond.  The last time the Spiders played in Blacksburg was 1985.  Final score:  Richmond 24, Virginia Tech 14.  The Odyssey thinks it is more likely that Richmond recovers from its hangover to play to its potential than Marshall even though the Odyssey does not expect a Richmond upset.

At any rate, during our drives through the mountain roads this weekend, we will definitely keep an eye out for John Denver.

Page 14 of 31

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén